Cratylus and the Ancestors

Document Type : علمی - پژوهشی

Author

The Center for the Great Islamic Encyclopedia

Abstract

Abstract: Plato’s different and somehow contradictory views on etymology has long resulted in debates. In Cratylus and some other works he criticized etymology as a philosophical method. He denied any resemblance between things and their names so that the analysis of a name would not discover the essence of the thing. Yet he has practiced in his other works some etymological analyses which seems to be in opposition with his previous view and therefore there has been the debate if Plato at all believed in etymology as a philosophical method. Cratylus is generally believed as one of the so-called middle dialogues, i.e. those Plato wrote in the second phase of his philosophical career, while the aforementioned etymologies appear in the late dialogues. It shows that after Cratylus Plato in his late dialogues has changed his mind regarding etymology and its epistemological worth and subsequently inclined/tended to it. Plato disagrees etymology in Cratylus since he thinks the greek name-givers have failed to gain the truth about things so that the names they made do not correspond to the things themselves. The name-givers, called usually as law-givers by Plato, are the same ancestors who have founded/stablished the greek laws, norms, traditions and the opinions. In Cratylus Plato is suspicious to the knowledge of greek ancestors and his disagree with etymology is one of its consequences. However In his later works because of some unknown reasons he changes his previous view and praised the ancestors’ virtues and confirmed their superior knowledge. Simultaneous with the change, and opposed to what we find in Cratylus, in later dialogues it is said that the greek names in all aspects correspond to the objects and this seems to be, according to Plato, due to name-giver’s knowledge of the things. Thus the reason why Plato has asserted different views on etymology seems to be that he has changed his view regarding the ancestors. In this article the passages with the subject names, namegivers and ancestors will be collected and analyzed.

Keywords

References

  1. - ارسطو، مابعدالطبیعه، ترجمۀ شرف الدین خراسانی، تهران، انتشارات حکمت، 1379ش.
  2. - افلاطون، دورۀ آثار، ترجمۀ محمد حسن لطفی، تهران، انتشارات خوارزمی.
  3. - گمپرتس، تئودور، متفکران یونانی، ترجمۀ محمد حسن لطفی، تهران، انتشارات خوارزمی، 1375ش.
  4. - Allan, D. J. ‘The problem of Cratylus’, American Journal of Philology 75, 1954, 271–87.
  5. - Barney, Rachel, Names and Nature in Plato’s Cratylus, Routledge, New York & London, 2001.
  6. - Berg, R. M. van den, R. M., Proclus’ Commentary on the Cratylus in Context, Leiden, 2008.
  7. - Boys-Stones, G. R., Post-Hellenistic Philosophy, Oxford University Press, 2001.
  8. - Calvert, B. ‘Forms and flux in Plato’s Cratylus’, Phronesis 15, 1970, 26–47
  9. - Guthrie, W. K. C. A History of Greek Philosophy, Cambridge, 1962.
  10. - Hesiod, ‘Works and Days’, The Homeric Hymns and Homerica, with an English Translation by Hugh G. Evelyn-White, London, 1974.
  11. - Irwin, T. ‘Plato’s Heracliteanism’, Philosophical Quarterly 27, 1977, 1–13.
  12. - Kahn, Ch. H., ‘On Platonic chronology’, in Annas and Rowe, 2002, 93–127.
  13. - Kirk, G. S. ‘The Problem of Cratylus’, American Journal of Philology, 1951, 225-253.
  14. - Liddel, H. G.& Scott, R., A Greek-English Lexicon, Oxford, 1983.
  15. - Luce, J. V. ‘The date of the Cratylus’, American Journal of Philology 85, 1964, 136–54.
  16. - Mackenzie, M. M., ‘Putting the Cratylus in its place’, Classical Quarterly 36, 1986,124–50.
  17. - Owen, G. E. L. ‘The place of the Timaeus in Plato’s dialogues’, Classical Quarterly 47, 1953, 79–95.
  18. - Plato, The Dialogues, Translated by B. Jowett, M. A., Random Hause, New York, 1937.
  19. - Proclus, On Plato’s Cratylus, Translated by Brian Duvick, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York, 2007.
  20. - Ross, W. D. Plato’s Theory of Ideas, Oxford, 1951.
  21. - id ‘The date of Plato’s Cratylus’, Revue Internationale de Philosophie, 32, 1955, 187–96.
  22. - Sedley, D., Plato’s Cratylus, New York, 2003.
  23. - Id, “Plato on Language” , in a Companion to Plato, ed. Hugh H. Benson, Wiley-Blackwell, 2006.
  24. - Taylor, A. E., Plato, The Man and his Work, London, 1929.
  25. - Young, C. M. ‘Plato and computer dating’, Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 12, 1994, 227–50.

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 13 December 2016
  • Revise Date: 01 January 2022
  • Accept Date: 31 December 2020

Share

How to cite

Statistics