The problem of subject and subjectivity: with a focus on Ortega y Gasset’s conception of Pueblo

Document Type : علمی - پژوهشی

Author

Department of History, Faculty of literature and Human Sciences, University of Shahid Beheshti, Tehran. Iran

10.29252/kj.2022.223969.1069

Abstract

idegger’s the authentic Dasein or Sartre’s pour soi existence (responsible free man). By paying attention to the ontological, anthropological and cognitive foundations of the phenomenological-existentialist perspective, however it is possible to cast doubts on these answers. Therefore, any determination based on originality and authenticity, such as the two above mentioned propositions, may be considered inadequate or even contradictory. It seems that a different (or conflicting) path must be taken to reach this unique subject and subjectivity. In order to provide a perspective on this phenomenological and existentialist subject, this paper concentrates on the views of Jose Ertega y Gasset. Marcel’s priority of être over avoir, Heidegger’s distinction between zuhandenheit and vorhandenheit, Hussel’s idea of the eternal unfinnished perception of things, Heidegger’s interpretation of das Geviert, are some important phenomenological and existentialist insights which pave the way for a new solution. In accordance with all the mentioned insiths and as a sum up of them, Ortega’s unique definition of la circumstancia, as well as his conception of horizonte de posibilidade and, ultimately, his Pueblo promise the emergence of a new subject and subjectivity. Pueblo- one of the most frequently used terms in Ortega’s system of ideas- can be considered as a non-individual and, at the same time, non-universal subject, a determination of subjectivity which is faithful to the foundations of phenomenological and existentialist philosophies.

Keywords


Merleau-Ponty, Maurice (1945), Phénoménologie de la perception, Paris: Gallimard.
______________________ (2005), phenomenology of perception, translated by: Colin Smit, London and New York, Routledge.
______________________ (1968), The Visible and the Invisible, Evanston: Northwestern Press.
Бердяев, Николай (1934), Я и мир объектов: Опыт философии одиночества и общения, Париж: YMCA PRESS.
Nikolas Berdyaev (2009), Solitude and Society, Boris Jakim (foreword), George Reavey (translator), CA: Semantron Press.
Ortega y Gasset, José (1970), Ideas y creencias, Madrid: Revista de occidente, S. A. Decima Edicion.
___________________ (2010), La rebelión de las masas, Ciudad de México: Fernando Robles Otero.
____________________ (1940), Obras de José Ortega y Gasset, Madrid: Espasa Calpe.